Interim report open for consultation

Michael Fourman presented the interim report today to the cross-party group for Science and Technology at the Scottish Parliament.

Digital Scotland Consultation

Update 23 June 2010 if you wish to comment on the draft consultation report, please use the comments section below this post. The consultation document will be launched on Wednesday 30th June.
Please comment on this and earlier posts to contribute to the development of a Digital Strategy for Scotland.
The development of digital society is changing the ways we live, work and play. These changes are global, but local action is required to maximise local benefit.
Scotland needs a Digital Strategy to remain competitive in a rapidly changing world. This should enable local enterprises to participate in the global digital economy, include local communities in the global digital society, and allow Scotland to exploit new opportunities — afforded by current and future technologies — for innovation in devolved areas of government.
To contribute to the factual basis on which such a strategy must be built, we will survey four major areas and conclude with our recommendations:

1. Users and benefits
• How may different communities be affected by digital society?
• To include communities of interest as well as geographic communities.
• To include business sectors as well as social groups.
• To assess the benefits digital inclusion may bring.
2. Infrastructure
• Geography and demographics
• Installed capacity
• Technology survey (copper, fibre, wifi, satellite, etc.).
• Technology foresight - five-year/ten-year.
3. Content and access
• Consider how Scottish policy may affect re-use of public-sector information in devolved matters (including, e.g. education, health, government).
• Public access – schools, libraries, parks.
4. Comparators
• We will consider a range of international comparators matched for demographics and geography, to see how both policy and practice elsewhere might inform a Scottish strategy.
5. Recommendations
• Our recommendations for policy and action will be founded on the evidence gathered in earlier sections.
• We will gather, and invite comment on policies and actions being proposed and adopted elsewhere, as well as novel suggestions for the Scottish context.

---

We invite public contributions to help us both shape and answer the questions we will address under each of these headings. We intend this to be a flexible process.

Each of the five headings above is linked to its own page, where you will find more detailed questions and discussion.

In the first instance, please contribute by commenting on the appropriate page (for general suggestions on content and process please comment on this page).

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam: spam will be rejected. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the committee or personal contact details). 

Always assume that participation online results in your comments being permanently available and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Digital Scotland: Users and benefits

We will identify groups, activities and communities that will be affected by Scotland's Digital Strategy. These will include communities of interest as well as geographic communities, and business sectors as well as social groups:

• Commerce
• Entertainment
• Farming and fishing
• Tourism
• Education
• Health
• Government

We will assess, and where possible quantify, the requirements of different groups and the benefits digital inclusion may bring.

Economic framework

We hope to demonstrate that:

• Broadband is not only the web and email—it's also a radio, a tv, a daily newspaper, a library and a town hall.
• Digital infrastructure contributes to education, health care, energy, public safety, and democratic engagement.
• It supports collaboration and innovation, and provides producers and entrepreneurs with access to global markets.
• It makes remote communities more sustainable, and supports social inclusion.

---

Please add your comments and contributions below.

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the committee or personal contact details). 

Always remember that participation online results in your comments being permanently available, and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Digital Scotland: Infrastructure

We will identify the capabilities of current and future technologies that may contribute to Scotland's digital infrastructure, and examine their applicability in relation to Scotland's geography and demographics.

• Geography and demographics
  • Urban Scotland
  • Rural Scotland
  • Suburban Scotland
• Current and planned provision
• Technology summary
  • Fibre
  • Copper
    • POTS
    • Co-ax
    • Power Line
  • Wireless
  • Satellite
• Technology forsight
  • Computation
    • Moore's Law
  • Communication
    • Nielsen's Law
  • Data
    • The Data Deluge

---

Please add your comments and contributions below.

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the committee or personal contact details). 

Always remember that participation online results in your comments being permanently available, and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Digital Scotland: Content and access

We will consider how Scottish policy may affect re-use of public-sector information in Scotland — in particular, in devolved matters (which include, e.g., education, health, government).
What barriers exist to universal digital inclusion in Scotland?br /> What opportunities may be provided for public access – e.g. through schools, libraries, community meeting places and parks?

---

We invite contributions to help us both shape and answer the questions we will address.

Please comment below.

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the committee or personal contact details). 

Always remember that participation online results in your comments being permanently available, and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Digital Scotland: Comparators

This section will benchmark a selection of local initiatives and international comparators, in order both to learn from practice elsewhere, and to identify the plans and capabilities of our present and future competitors.

---

Please add your comments and contributions below.

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the committee or personal contact details). 

Always remember that participation online results in your comments being permanently available, and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Digital Scotland: Recommendations

Our final report will include recommendations for policy and action. These will be founded on the evidence gathered in earlier sections.
The draft recommendations listed below may be amended in the light of further evidence.

Draft recommendations

1. An integrated backbone providing universal access should be developed as strategic infrastructure for Scotland.
   This could be achieved by a combination of FTTC (fibre to the cabinet) in built-up areas, with sparser fiber provision supplemented by wireless distribution, in less-populated areas.
2. Regulation should be made to require open data on core infrastructure and competitive access to nodes and ducts.
   This will enable innovation and the development of local community broadband in areas of market failure.
3. All future transport infrastructures and urban developments should be pre-installed with tubes into which optical fibre may later be installed, or ”blown”, as a planning requirement.
4. Open internet access should be provided, in schools, libraries, community centres etc., to support digital inclusion.
5. A standard open licence for public data should be adopted and used.

Recommendations made elsewhere

1. Install broadband fiber as part of every federally-funded infrastructure project.
2. Deploy broadband fiber to every library, school, community health care center, and public housing facility in the United States
3. Create incentives for providers to install multiple lines of fiber as new networks are rolled out.
4. Encourage greater wireless broadband and reduce barriers to deployment.
5. Vouchers to allow low-income students to get broadband Internet service at their homes.

These are taken from various sources, including Google's suggestions for US national bb plan.

---

We invite your comments on applicability to Scotland of the recommendations listed above and your contributions to help us formulate and shape our own recommendations.

Please comment below.

All comments will be moderated – please, no spam. Please indicate in what capacity you are writing. Indicate clearly any parts of your message not intended for open publication (private messages for the working group or personal contact details). 

Always remember that participation online results in your comments being permanently available, and open to being republished in other media. Be aware that libel, defamation, copyright and data protection laws apply.

Second meeting

The RSE Digital Scotland Working Group met today.

It was agreed that Professor Michael Fourman would be the chair of the working group.

A draft scoping paper that had previously been circulated was discussed and a number of comments and suggestions made - these will be taken on board and a revised scoping paper, suitable for briefing organisations and individuals we wish to consult, will be circulated.

To help frame the questions for consultation, we will build the framework of issues that the final report may be expected to cover, and perhaps to identify some areas that it would not be feasible or worthwhile to address in the course of this work.

The two pieces of work identified above will be completed before the next meeting of the group, on 10th February. Interviewing of witnesses and gathering of evidence will commence after this meeting.

Digital Scotland

An initial meeting of the RSE Digital Scotland Working Group (DSWG) was held on the 13th November 2009. In addition to a good attendance at the meeting, several other key individuals who had other commitments that day indicated that they would be prepared to contribute towards the development of a Digital Scotland report / advice paper.

It was the view of the working group that there is an opportunity for Scotland to develop a more radical and visionary approach to the use of digital technology than was perhaps possible for the UK as a whole.

It was agreed that it would be worthwhile for the RSE to develop an Advice Paper with a view to advancing digital development in Scotland. It is envisaged that this work will take place over several months with members of the working group engaging in interviews with key groups between meetings.

The overall aim of the DSWG will to be to develop a vision of the society that Scotland can become by embracing the opportunities offered by digital technology. This vision should be about individuals, society, the environment and the economy.

Digital technology should be seen as a vehicle that can and should produce societal benefits and consideration should be given on the broadest frame to what can be achieved.

Digital Britain

A White Paper, Digital Britain, produced by a committee chaired by Lord Carter, was published in June 2009. It was envisaged as the UK Government's strategic vision for ensuring that the UK is at the leading edge of the global digital economy. It comments that:

The Digital Britain agenda encompasses a broad spectrum of policies, some of which are the responsibility of devolved administrations. Not all the initiatives referred to in the report, therefore, are UK-wide. The UK Government hopes to work in partnership with the devolved administrations to deliver a successful digital economy across the UK but recognises that for some policy areas, such as education and some public services, a different approach may be taken in different parts of the UK.

While many of the recommendations of the report apply unchanged to Scotland, Scotland faces particular challenges, such as large and remote rural areas, particular opportunities of scale and, arguably, better-skilled human capital, not shared by the rest of the UK.

The Royal Society of Edinburgh has concluded therefore that it would be appropriate to undertake a review under the heading Digital Scotland, with the intention of producing a report to advocate measures in this domain that could and should be undertaken in Scotland.
The Digital Scotland report will build on the Carter Report to:

1. Review scientific, economic and social questions relating to Scotland’s inclusion in the global digital economy, and to digital inclusion in Scotland;
2. Provide an evidence base, and identify challenges and opportunities for development of digital infrastructure, and its exploitation in Scotland.